(Hats-off to Corey Meyer over at The Blood of My Kindred)

Since its inception, I have strived to remain fairly a-political here on “Blog or Die.” Still, every now and then I feel the need to rant about the misrepresentation and/or manipulation of history in support of an agenda. These past few months have given us much reason for concern. From the textbook myths of Black Confederate battalions to the misrepresentation of the Constitution, America desperately needs a history lesson. My recent criticism of the Tea Party garnered me lots of emails (most ‘pro’ but some ‘con’) and even an award. As that post dealt with what I consider to be political propaganda, this post deals with flat out lunacy.

Now I will be the first to admit that I used to like the original Glenn Beck Show. As a Libertarian, I enjoyed the fact that he attacked both sides of the aisle evenly. I also appreciated his journey toward faith. Unfortunately, something happened to Mr. Beck over the last few years, as he has gone from a witty political-alarmist to a ranting-village-idiot. From routinely misquoting Thomas Jefferson and George Washington, to comparing the president to Karl Marx, Beck is just as ignorant and outrageous as those he claims to despise. He is, in my opinion, a more-conservative version of Keith Obermann whose primary goal is to fan the flames of political discontent and further the divide between parties.

That’s entertainment folks and I get that. I understand that these guys/gals are media whores trying to get ratings. What I don’t get is how these seemingly intelligent people can be so stupid, so often. Frankly, it scares me that many members of their audiences believe what they say to be the truth, and this leads to the propagation of misinformation. Corey Meyer over at The Blood of My Kindred recently posted a video of Glenn Beck defending the Three-Fifths Compromise. What makes this clip disturbing is his interpretation of it and the claim that if blacks were counted as a full person they could never be set free. What?

According to Mr. Beck, anyone who finds the Three-Fifths clause to be offensive has quote: "a lack of understanding of history, who the Founding Fathers were, what the Constitution says, or it is just cowardice." He then says, "The Three-Fifths Clause...that's an outrage, unless you know why they put that in there. They put that in there because if slaves in the South were counted as full human-beings, they could never abolish slavery. ...It was a tremendous story about our Founders, about the genius of the Constitution."  

Beck's statement implies to me, that the Founders put that clause in there as a steeping-stone towards emancipation. That is wrong. I blogged about this back in October of 2009 when I was reading Gary Wills’ book “Negro President” Jefferson and the Slave Power. At the time I was struck by how much the federal government was influenced, even controlled by the institution of bondage. My conclusion: slavery equaled southern political power, thus southern political power required slavery. Chapter 1 really caught my attention:

In the sixty-two years between Washington’s election and the Compromise of 1850, for example, slaveholders controlled the presidency for fifty-years, the Speaker’s chair for forty-one years, and the chairmanship of House Ways and Means [the most important committee] for forty-two years. The only men to be re-elected president – Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, and Jackson – were all slaveholders. The men who sat in the Speaker’s chair the longest – Henry Clay, Andrew Stevenson, and Nathaniel Macon – were slaveholders. Eighteen out of thirty-one Supreme Court justices were slaveholders.

To quote Corey's quote (taken from Digital History):

How can Mr. Beck imply that the Three-Fifths Compromise was added to benefit those who fell under it? Maybe you can twist this into some form of validity, but my issue is with intent. This was a way for the South to retain a competitive share of political power and NOT in retrospect, a step closer towards the abolishment of the institution of slavery. In order for the South's power to grow (and it did), slavery had to grow (and it did).

And why can’t anyone ever admit that many of the Founding Fathers were racists, the majority of southern framers were slaveholders, and that the very country that was founded on the principals of liberty and independence spent hundreds of years withholding that very freedom from a large portion of its inhabitants because of their race? It doesn’t make them any less important or revolutionary. It simply acknowledges their prejudices which must be viewed within the context of the period.

I have no less admiration for the Founding Fathers because I see them as what they truly were, men, with the same faults and sins of their colleagues and contemporaries. They were brilliant, and ambitious, and we should look to them for example, BUT at the same time we must remember that they were human and capable of being wrong. Franklin was a playboy who cheated on his wife. Washington refused to allow the recruitment of blacks into his army despite their dwindling numbers. Jefferson likely wanted America to be more like France. They would not support either political party today, nor would they appreciate the fringe parties who have hijacked their legacies.

I think that I can say, without a doubt, that they were intelligent enough to know their history and would be just as outraged as I am that Glenn Beck is ‘re-inventing’ his own form to support an agenda. Worse off, I wonder what those who fell under the Three-Fifths Compromise would think about Mr. Beck’s claim that it was really a step towards abolishing slavery. 

Someone once said that Adolph Hitler was a good leader up until he killed all those Jews. Thank God he didn’t have his own talk-show.

This week I was contacted by our friends at the Civil War Preservation Trust in reference to a photograph that I had taken several years ago. In 2008, I won second place in the CWPT’s photography contest for their Battlefield Threat category. The CWPT is currently developing a Civil War curriculum and creating a two minute film about battlefield preservation. My image, Modern "Raid" will be included. The film, as part of their curriculum, will be available on the CWPT’s website for free download to all, but specifically K12 teachers. They are also going to sell the complete curriculum in print & CD form (28 lesson plans with associated worksheets, PowerPoints, and exams) at cost to teachers who wish to have a hard copy. I am honored to have my image used in what promises to be an extraordinary teaching aid. Who better to educate the public about the importance of battlefields than the CWPT.

AND speaking of films…we are just days away from releasing our DVD. Stay tuned!

My recovery is going fairly well and I have my good days and bad days. Today is a good day because I get to share another exceptional guest post in my absence. Dr. Linda Sundquist-Nassie is a gifted teacher and historian who I have had the privilege of communicating with over the last few months. Linda has just been added to the list of contributing writers for Patriots of the American Revolution magazine and has some great pieces coming out this year. Today her post examines the Fitzhughs.

Treasures Beyond Measure
by Dr. Linda Sundquist-Nassie

I think those of us who love history are often sentimentally attached to family treasures and items that tell a piece of our history, remind us of a specific time and place, often connect us to a special relative, and actually give us a tangible link to both our personal history and our national heritage.  Those pieces of furniture or silver, paintings or letters, diaries, textiles, weapons are all preserved so that our story continues and our descendants will be linked through us to those who lived before us, insuring our own posterity.  (A wonderful book that explores the emotional connection, lore, and responsibility that our family heirlooms carry is Lisa Tracy’s “Objects of Our Affection.”  It’s a lovely, emotional read that will connect with family historians everywhere.)

One of my favorite “treasures” ironically is not a tangible item at all, but still it links me to my ancestors and the accomplishments of their lives.  I love the items that have been passed down to me beginning with my first ancestors that arrived here aboard the Susan Constant to Jamestowne in 1607, but I have found great interest in my family “mottos” that those English ancestors proudly displayed.  Arriving from Europe, many came looking for new opportunities but sporting their connections to their European heritage and any claims to royalty or privilege that they had.  Family crests, titles, mottos were proudly displayed as unique descriptions of specific family lines.  Perhaps sometimes appearing presumptuous, but interesting and in some cases, inspiring for descendants to treasure, as a standard by which family members proudly identified their lives. 

My favorite family motto comes from my Fitzhugh family line and it is one that I have chosen as my “motto”, my signature line and standard by which I have  tried to lead my life, raise my children, teach my students, and “stay the course” for my life’s work.  PRO PATRIA SEMPER  was  the Fitzhugh motto.  Translated from the Latin it means “FOR MY COUNTRY ALWAYS”.   What greater family treasure can there be then the gift of patriotic service and commitment to one’s country above all else?  This motto defines patriotism, commitment, and faithfulness – treasures beyond measure.

If you investigate the Fitzhughs who fought in the American Revolution, you will find many participants, serving in a variety of roles, leading lives in step with their family motto:  William Fitzhugh, elected to represent Virginia at the 1st Continental Congress in 1779 and a member of the Virginia State House of Delegates and State Senate in the 1780’s.  He worked hard to help establish liberty in America and was a very close friend of George Washington.  In fact, the last time George Washington left Mt. Vernon before his death, was to travel to Alexandria to visit William Fitzhugh.  (An interesting note:  William Fitzhugh’s  daughter married George Washington Parke Custis, the adopted grandson of George and Martha Washington, and their daughter, Mary married Robert E. Lee.)

My favorite story is about a cousin, fondly known as William “War Billy” Fitzhugh.  At the start of the Revolution, “War Billy” resigned his British commission, knowing that he could not fight against America.  Living in Maryland with his wife and children, the British command told him that if he would stay out of the conflict, they would pay him half his salary and they would leave him alone, since by this point, he was nearly blind.  He refused, so they imprisoned him and burned his house down, his wife and family barely escaping with their lives.  Eventually, he was released, and he returned to the Maryland area and lived out the remainder of his life, near where he is buried today.

So many stories and so many events where people put their love of country ahead of their own personal hopes and dreams.   It’s a fact that we need to remember in these times when personal comfort takes far too important a role ahead of wanting to do our patriotic duty. As a teacher, I see fewer and fewer children being taught by their parents the duty they owe their country as a result of the blessing of being a citizen of the United States.  The sacred honor that they should hold needs to be instilled in the next generation of Americans.  For me, my family motto is the greatest treasure from my ancestors that I hold.  I love the paintings and furniture and quilts and diaries that have been passed down to me, but the daily reminder “For My Country Always” is my guide and my personal connection to my history and my family.

BIO: Dr. Linda Sundquist-Nassie lives in the foothills of the beautiful gold country of northern California, an area rich in American history and folklore.  She has taught American history and literature in high school and middle school in a neighboring district for over 35 years.  She is the author of “The Poetess of Song, The Life of Mary Shindler”.  She is currently working on a multi-generational book about another branch of her family, scheduled for publication in the fall of 2012.

OWN YOUR COPY OF "THE ANGEL OF MARYE’S HEIGHTS" ON DVD

It is with great pleasure that Right Stripe Media can announce the official release date of “The Angel of Marye’s Heights” DVD as January 2011. This commemorates the beginning of the Sesquicentennial (150th Anniversary) of the American Civil War. This DVD will be available online in the coming weeks.

We invite you to share this announcement with your friends and view our dramatic short titled “The Mercy Scene.” This touching re-enactment depicts Richard Kirkland’s act of courage and compassion as we envision it on that fateful December day in 1862. Watch Video Here: http://www.vimeo.com/18233614

This is just one of the DVD’s bonus features. In addition to the newly enhanced half-hour documentary, you’ll get 6 additional videos including interviews and behind the scenes segments. Thank you for your support. We are pleased to make this remarkable story available to you. For more, visit the film’s website at www.theangelmovie.com.

Clint Ross and Michael Aubrecht
Right Stripe Media LLC
www.pinstripepress.net/RSM.html

Hugh Harrington (above) is a fellow author and historian of whom I have the greatest respect for. We share the same publishers at The History Press and Patriots of the American Revolution and I am doing everything I can just to keep up with him. Hugh’s incredibly long list of credits include multiple books on Milledgeville GA and insights on both Sherlock Holmes and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.  For more on Hugh’s published works visit his website at www.hughharrington.com/. We often chat via email and this week our discussion revolved around my last blog post on Washington’s crossing of the Delaware River. Hugh had a wonderful way of painting this event with words. He wrote: