Being ?honest? about Abe
I've always been somewhat troubled over the subject of Abraham Lincoln. Not that I despise the man or anything, but I certainly have conflicting opinions over some of his policies and practices. Lincoln was in my opinion, a prototypical politician who took liberties while in office that I simply cannot condone. The idea of our government turning the troops on its own people (for ANY reason) disturbs me greatly. Perhaps that is why I am so drawn to the Libertarian Party.
I’ll certainly agree that Abraham Lincoln was an extraordinary speaker and emancipator, who perhaps held his position of office at the most difficult time in our nation’s history. That said I was shocked to find out just how many people here in my area consider him to be nothing short of a tyrant.
I noticed a trend over the last few months when discussing Civil War history with attendees at various functions and speaking engagements. The opinion over Lincoln seems to fluctuate between a politician who overstepped his bounds - to an evil dictator that trampled on the Constitution and desecrated the South. (That one may be a bit over the top.) Still, the more people I’ve spoken to, the more I’ve come to realize that Lincoln plays the part of the villain in many people’s perceptions of the Civil War.
I will say that this poll is anything but scientific. It arose as I quote Lincoln’s letter to the Union troops following their defeat here at Fredericksburg in some of my talks and people always come up to me after and voice their dislike for the man. They are all white, mostly Protestants, both genders, many veterans, many retirees, and most lifelong southerners. Many are history buffs themselves. Some are members of the SCV, UDC, LOS, and CWPT. Some are re-enactors, teachers, govt. contractors and preachers. Many have Confederate ancestors and I believe that is a major factor. All of them are certainly entitled to their opinions and I thank them for sharing.
I personally have little interest in the subject of Abraham Lincoln nowadays as other aspects of Civil War history have caught my fancy. I am however fascinated to discover that he is not nearly as popular as I thought, even now in the 21st-century. Actually it appears to be quite the opposite. Many people down here in Central Virginia really dislike him, even to this day.
I wonder if people up north have the same dislike for Jefferson Davis? Or even care enough to have an opinion on the man at all?