John Bell Hood remembered
Some of you may remember a fun feature that I was commissioned to do for the Jan/Feb issue of Civil War Historian magazine in which I selected my Top-10 Confederate Generals. READ PDF. The goal of this piece was to generate some reader feedback and I was very honored to have a descendant of General John Bell Hood send a letter to the editor voicing his gratitude for me including his ancestor. Gen. Hood in my opinion has always been underrated due to his lack of success in the western theater. However, his contributions in the east, along with his physical sacrifice in the name of the South's Cause cannot be forgotten. In addition to the wonderful conversations that this article has opened, I am most thankful for being made an honorary member of the John Bell Hood Society, a membership that I will treasure always. Below is the letter that is running in the March/April issue of CWH:
Dear Civil War Historian,
Author Michael Aubrecht’s inclusion of General John Bell Hood in “The Top Ten Confederate Generals” feature in the January/February 2008 issue of Civil War Historian surely raised the eyebrows of many—and the ire of some—in the Civil War history community. Mr. Aubrecht wrote in the “Criteria” section: “Another admirable trait was Hood’s fearless admission of faults when defeated; in addition to accepting the blame for tactical failures, he routinely praised his men in after-action reports.
”Many modern Civil War authors—most prominently Wiley Sword—have gone to great efforts to paint General Hood as a drug-addicted, lovelorn, commander who connived his way into command of the Army of Tennessee, and after launching a quixotic campaign into Tennessee, intentionally slaughtered his own troops at Franklin in a fit of vengeful rage over the failure at Spring Hill, and then blamed the defeat on his soldiers. To succeed in this illusion, these authors have concealed virtually all of the sizeable amount of historical evidence and testimony of both Hood and his supporters, while giving center stage to Hood’s critics and detractors.
Many Civil War enthusiasts will be surprised to learn of the following comments by Hood, none of which appear in Sword’s acclaimed book, The Confederacy’s Last Hurrah, or any other major books on Hood’s Tennessee Campaign or the Army of Tennessee.
In his postwar memoirs, Advance and Retreat, Hood praised the “extraordinary gallantry” of the soldiers of the Army of Tennessee at Franklin, and compared them to his own namesake brigade, the famous Hood’s Texas Brigade: “The attack (at Franklin), which entailed so great a sacrifice of life, had become a necessity as imperative as that which impelled Gen. Lee to order the assault at Gaines’ Mill, when our troops charged across an open space, a distance of one mile, under a most galling fire of musketry and artillery, against an enemy heavily entrenched. The heroes in that action fought not more gallantly than the soldiers of the Army of Tennessee upon the fields of Franklin.”
Hood praised his soldiers in his Official Report on the Battle of Franklin, writing, “Never did troops fight more gallantly” and in his resignation letter wrote, “When the fortunes of war were against us, the same faithful soldiers remained true to their flag, and with rare exceptions followed it in retreat as they had borne it in advance.”
Hood’s affection for his men is well documented in historical records, but rarely revealed in modern Civil War literature. Major James W. Ratchford of General D.H. Hill’s staff recalled a scene immediately after the Battle of Gaines’ Mill: “Early in the same night . . . I came upon General Hood sitting on a cracker box. As I approached, he looked up at me, and I could see tears streaming down his cheeks. His brigade had lost heavily, and all about him were the dead and wounded. I spoke to him and he replied brokenly, ‘Just look here Major, at all these dead and suffering men, and every one of them as good as I am, yet I am untouched.’”
Regarding acceptance of blame for the failures of the Tennessee Campaign, Hood wrote in his memoirs, “Whilst I failed utterly to give battle at Spring Hill…” even though Major James Ratchford wrote: “He (Hood) said further that he sent staff officers to Cheatham several times, urging him to place troops across the pike to intercept the fleeing Federals. Major Blanton and Major Hamilton, both of Hood’s staff, each told me personally that he had carried the orders to Gen Cheatham. That grand old hero (Gen. Hood) died without ever defending himself, allowing the world to believe that he was responsible for the failure.”
In his resignation letter Hood wrote of the Tennessee Campaign, “I am alone responsible for its conception . . .”
Near the end of the Nashville retreat Private W.G. Davenport of the 6th Texas Cavalry wrote that General Hood rode up, “Looking worn and tired but with kindly words for all, said to the soldiers, ‘Boys, this is all my fault.’”
Diarist Mary Chesnut wrote of Hood in her Diary From Dixie: “How plainly he spoke out these dreadful words. ‘My defeat and discomfiture!’ ‘My army is destroyed.’ ‘My losses!’ He said he had nobody to blame but himself.”
The Roman historian Cicero wrote that a historian “ . . . shall suppress nothing that is true. Moreover, there shall be no suspicion of partiality in his writing, or of malice.” Unfortunately, many modern Civil War authors ignore Cicero’s charge, damaging not only scholarship, but also the reputations of historical characters.
Congratulations to Michael Aubrecht for searching for the truth, and having the courage to express what many will consider heresy.
Sam Hood
Collateral descendent of General Hood
President of the John Bell Hood Historical Society