« May 2008 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31




You are not logged in. Log in
Pinstripe Press Blog: Author and Historian Michael Aubrecht
May 25, 2008
Something's missing?

I am about to brand myself as a hypocrite after commenting on people’s hyper-sensitivity over Abraham Lincoln (below)…but I too have been bothered by something that I’d like to get off my chest.

Last week I mentioned my recent trip to the ‘Stonewall’ Jackson Shrine. I live approximately 8 miles up the road from Guinea Station and the SJS is one of my favorite spots here in the entire Fredericksburg/Spotsylvania area. The building and grounds are beautiful, the interpreters are always wonderful and the site is never-ever crowded. It’s a hidden treasure so to speak and my children have been instructed to scatter my ashes on the lawn there when I’m gone (yes, for real). Currently I am in the process of putting together a detailed photo essay on the story of the site that hosted Jackson’s last days and I will post a link when it is completed.

My issue today is in regards the American flag being the only flag that flies on the site. Unlike our local battlefields, this location has absolutely nothing to do with the Union’s story. Jackson’s death is what hallowed the ground, nothing more. As he did not survive the war and there was no reconciliation between him and the Union, I wonder what he would think about that flag being the only one flying above a shrine that is dedicated solely to his memory.

To me it’s like putting American flags on Confederate graves. Those that survived the Civil War had an opportunity to rejoin their fellow Americans in one nation, but those who died before the South’s surrender did not. Would they condone their adversary’s colors flying over their sacred sites in place of their own?

I understand that the National Park Service flies American flags on their properties, but in this instance, I wonder why there isn’t at least one Confederate banner somewhere on the grounds to acknowledge Jackson’s cause. Maybe I’ll ask my friends in the NPS if they have a take on this. They do an extraordinary job with the SJS, but this bothers me. I’d love to get some other people’s opinions too. Feel free to comment or email.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 6:39 PM EDT
Updated: May 26, 2008 9:30 AM EDT
Post Comment | View Comments (3) | Permalink | Share This Post

May 26, 2008 - 7:06 PM EDT

Name: "RW"

I don't beleive the NPS, ARE VERY 'FRIENDLY" to the the Confederacy. Its not PC.

May 26, 2008 - 11:28 PM EDT

Name: "Michael Aubrecht"

Thanks for the comment RW. I personally know plenty of NPS people that are very 'CSA' respectful and friendly, but I get where you are coming from. We have one of the best NPS teams here in Fredericksburg and they have always been very generous and helpful to me in my research. Still, I am puzzled over the lack of a Confederate banner at what is essentially a 'Confederate' shrine. I’ve studied Jackson more than any other subject and although it is purely my own speculation, I believe that he would disapprove of the CSA flag being absent.

May 28, 2008 - 8:15 PM EDT

Name: "Eric Mink"

Something to consider, Michael, from someone who used to work at the Stonewall Jackson Shrine. These are my own personal views.

The flag that flies at the Shrine today is not the flag of the United States 1861-1865, so therefore really does not represent the Civil War Union Army, which fought under a flag with anywhere between 33-35 stars. The flag at the Shrine represents the organization that is the steward of the Shrine, the National Park Service, which is an agency of today's Federal Government. The same goes for the flags flown outside the Fredericksburg Visitor Center and the Chancellorsville Visitor Center.

Personally, if the Confederate flag were to be flown from a flagpole at the Shrine, I might view it as a perpetuation of a sense of division, and of course our country is no longer divided. The current flag contains 50 stars, one for each state, including those that were associated with the Confederacy. That also includes Jackson's Virginia.

If you're still concerned, feel free to send the park's superintendent a letter with your suggestion. 

View Latest Entries