« December 2009 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
Best History Sites on the Web


Bookstore
Order Online





What I'm Reading
"General George Washington" by Edward G. Lengel

What I'm Writing
Lion in the Valley: "Stonewall" Jackson's 1862 Valley Campaign (CWHC 2010 Muster)

BLOG, or DIE. A historian's journey through the Revolution

Visit the official Richard Kirkland documentary website and blog

Saturday, 19 December 2009
Blizzards and book reviews

Most people in the east will remember today as the “Blizzard of 2009.” The snow is nearing the two feet mark in some places here in central Virginia. As I type this, I am unable to see much of anything out my window and the snow showers continue to fall. Today is also the day that the FLS ran the very first review for my new book on Confederate encampments. As many readers will not make it out to the store in time to get their copy, I took it upon myself to make sure I did. What follows is my adventure and a wonderful critique that I am very humbled by.

 
 
 

FOCUS ON CAMP LIFE
The Civil War in Spotsylvania County: Confederate Campfires at the Crossroads by Michael Aubrecht. Book Review by Erik F. Nelson for The Free Lance-Star Town & County (12/19/09)

One-hundred-thousand soldiers were killed or wounded during the battles of Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, Wilderness and Spotsylvania Court House. This number  reflects a tragic loss, but the majority of deaths during the Civil War, by a factor of two to one, were not battlefield-related, but the result of disease in camp.

That more soldiers died in camp than in actual fighting or even on campaign, is explained through a variety of contributing conditions. Thousands of farm boys who joined the armies were without immunities to childhood diseases. Other communicable diseases resulted from poor camp sanitation, which had to be learned and enforced. Young men, living outdoors, became weakened by bad food, inadequate shelter, worn-out clothing, and hard duty.

Camp life was a large part of military life and the presence of the two principal eastern armies in and around Fredericksburg from 1862 to 1864 left their mark on the landscape as well as in the written record. The huge Northern army occupied much of Stafford County. Southern units camped in Spotsylvania County, including several places that are now a part of the city of Fredericksburg.

The remnants of camps are still evident in areas of the region that have not yet been fully developed. The best time to see them is in the winter months, when the thick Virginia foliage is down. That time of year, however, also makes it painfully evident how miserable those encampments had to have been.

Michael Aubrecht, a Fredericksburg-area writer and historian, explores this quieter aspect of the Civil War in a new book called "The Civil War in Spotsylvania County: Confederate Campfires at the Crossroads."

There are several classic studies on the experience of soldiering, such as Bell I. Wiley's "The Life of Johnny Reb," but Aubrecht does not try to reprise these types of works. Instead, he focuses on Spotsylvania County and presents various sub-themes, through a wide range of first-person accounts from Confederates who were in this region.

The author includes sections on soldier diet, crime and punishment, disease, the experience of winter quarters and so on. The collection of first-person accounts includes the words of generals, such as commanders like Robert E. Lee and Thomas J. "Stonewall" Jackson, as well as those of private soldiers, who may have been less literate, but were certainly no less descriptive. The format consists of a short introduction for each chapter, followed by a series of primary documents.

The use of primary sources provides a striking immediacy, which in turn, carries potential insight. In the chapter on disease, for instance, a soldier recounts nights in bivouac broken by the persistent coughing and labored breathing of thousands of unhealthy men.

This is not a story of banners and bugles, but rather of the curse of war itself-once described by historian Bruce Catton as "the ugly fever-sickness that came upon young men who ate bad food and went to sleep wet to wake up cold."

Another chapter notes the relative youth of the Confederate army, which certainly applied to the Northern armies as well. We often see Civil War re-enactors with full beards, some of them quite gray. Large armies, however, are usually comprised of very young men, teenagers in fact, who have little facial hair to grow. Aubrecht's volume quietly presents these types of realities, always buttressed by his selection of first-person sources.

One section touches on the presence of African-Americans in the Confederate camps. The author includes material showing them to have served as cooks and body servants, but is cautious about claiming that they also served as soldiers, which has become a somewhat controversial subject.

To his credit, Aubrecht does not shy away from presenting what evidence has been used by others to claim that slaves fought in the Confederate army, but equally to his credit, he does not generate unsubstantiated conclusions.

Other chapters examine the famous religious revivals that swept the Confederate camps, the experience of the families of those who were in the army, and the types of letters that soldiers wrote to wives and sweethearts.

Again, Aubrecht picks up the telling details, such as the scarcity of paper upon which to write a letter home or young men describing women, probably very similar to their own mothers, arriving at Fredericksburg to look for dead loved ones.

The History Press has an attractive presentation, although a mixed reputation for what they bring into print. Happily, this volume by Michael Aubrecht is a worthwhile compilation of first-person accounts that can be enjoyed for their own sake or used as a ready reference for other research.

The Confederate encampments that saw so much of this region's Civil War history wait silently in the woods of Spotsylvania County and Fredericksburg for explorers young and old. This book gives them voice.

Erik F. Nelson is a founding member of the Central Virginia Battlefields Trust and senior planner for the city of Fredericksburg.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 3:54 PM EST
Updated: Saturday, 19 December 2009 4:14 PM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (1) | Permalink | Share This Post
Wednesday, 16 December 2009

You’ve seen the trailer, met the cast, and soon you can view a preview of “The Angel of Marye’s Heights.” Stay tuned.

While you are waiting: Here’s a link to my latest interview for Patrick Whalen of Uncommon History. It’s a real privilege and I thank him.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 11:27 AM EST
Updated: Thursday, 17 December 2009 10:18 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Tuesday, 15 December 2009
In anticipation of our official preview of The Angel of Marye's Heights, I would like to introduce you to the cast and crew:


MEGAN HICKS
According to her website, “Megan Hicks survived the Baby Boom with her sense of humor intact.” She lives in Fredericksburg, Virginia, where she writes, tells stories, produces award-winning audios, teaches origami, and makes trash art. Megan is a direct descendant of Scotch-Irish peasants, who tells original & traditional stories, folk & fairy tales (intact & fractured), historical fiction, literary tales, family stories, and ghost stories ranging from pleasantly shivery to truly grisly. Exposed at a tender age to oilfield humor, tv evangelists and fairy tales, she brings this quirky legacy to storytelling audiences of all ages. Visit her website at www.meganhicks.com

JOHN CUMMINGS
An avid historian, John is a native of Northern Virginia with a life long interest in the American Civil War. Since moving to Spotsylvania County in 1999 he has authored numerous articles for local and national publications in addition to his first book. John currently serves as Chairman of the Friends of Fredericksburg Area Battlefields, Director of the Spotsylvania Battlefield Education Association, and was a former Chairman of the Spotsylvania Courthouse Tourism and Special Events Commission. He also served as a historical consultant for the former Federal Hill Foundation.

DON PFANZ
Donald C. Pfanz is a popular staff historian at Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park. A native of Gettysburg, Pa., Pfanz graduated from the College of William & Mary in Williamsburg in 1980, then joined the National Park Service. He first served at Petersburg National Battlefield and Fort Sumter National Monument before joining the Park Service in central Virginia. Don has written two books to date: Abraham Lincoln at City Point and Richard S. Ewell: A Soldier's Life and has appeared in multiple Civil War documentaries for the History Channel.

RICHARD WARREN II
Young Richard comes from a very talented family of ten. At the tender age of 9, Richard did a home-school project of a living history presentation. Since he had a love of the Civil War, he decided to do a presentation on a lesser known "hero", Sgt. Richard Kirkland “The Angel of Marye’s Heights.” Richard did such a wonderful portrayal, that he caught the eye of Michael Aubrecht, a Virginia historian and author who introduced him to filmmaker Clint Ross. Richard has had numerous opportunities and occasions to re-enact his presentation and has been invited to perform in additional theatrical presentations since.

SEAN ALLEN PRATT
Our (tentative) narrator Sean Allen Pratt's resume in film, television, and theater is extremely impressive and he has played many complex and dynamic characters over the course of his career. His credits include on film: Gods and Generals, Tuck Everlasting, Iron Jawed Angels and Ladder 49; on television roles: The District, Homicide and The Wire; and on stage: Oedipus The King and The Game Of Love And Chance. In addition to his acting, Sean holds seminars and workshops for actors looking to break into the biz. Visit his website at: www.seanprattpresents.com.

CLINT ROSS
Michael C. (Clint) Ross is a Writer, Producer, Director, and Editor. He is a recent MA graduate of Savannah College of Art & Design in Film and Television. He grew up in Athens, GA, and was a carpenter for nearly 10 years before spending time as a Young Adult minister in his hometown. After a personal and life changing conversation with Ken Wales, the Executive Producer of the film Amazing Grace, Clint pursued an education and career in film.

MICHAEL AUBRECHT
Michael has dedicated his studies to the histories of Major League Baseball, the Civil War, and more recently, the Founding Fathers. He has published multiple books, as well as hundreds of essays for Baseball-Almanac, The Free Lance-Star, Mort Kunstler Enterprises, Civil War Historian magazine, and Patriots of the American Revolution. Michael also hosts a popular Internet show titled "The Naked Historian." An experienced tour guide, speaker and radio guest, Michael is vice chairman of the National Civil War Life Foundation and the founder of The Jefferson Project. Visit his website at www.pinstripepress.net.

THE CREW
Left to right: Nazar Loun (1st Assistant Camera), Zach Graber (Director of Photography), Michael Aubrecht (Co-Producer), John Cummings (Uniforms & Equipment Supervisor), Michael C. Ross (Writer, Producer, Director, Editor), Clayton DeWet (Sound Mixer). Not pictured: Darren Dick (Motion Graphics)

 


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 10:04 PM EST
Updated: Thursday, 17 December 2009 8:00 AM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Monday, 14 December 2009
Thank you Sir.

Today’s Free Lance-Star has a short article about Peter S. Carmichael, the historian who delivered the keynote remarks on the battle's 147th anniversary. In it, Mr. Carmichael discusses our tendency to romanticize war as opposed to acknowledging the horror that it truly is. He uses Richard Kirkland’s story as a potential detractor from the memory of an engagement that resulted in a slaughter. I could not be more pleased with his comments as Clint Ross and I have gone to great lengths in our upcoming film on Kirkland to portray the misery and suffering that was witnessed by our main character.

According to Carmichael: "Every war, no matter how vicious and brutal the enemy might be, demands our awareness, our knowledge of what our troops are enduring on the front, or we lose our political check on how our nation wages war." He added that so, too, people can lose sight of what the Kirkland monument expresses: "the great universal riddle of being a soldier."  

Ironically, I just saw two newly edited sections of the film this weekend and the expert commentary and dramatic recreations are anything but romantic. Our story’s focus is completely built around the question of why a man would do what Kirkland did and why we remember it so today. Beyond a story of humanitarianism, it is equally presented as a commentary on the brutality of man. Mr. Carmichael’s comments are an indirect validation of our efforts and proves that we are definitely on the right track. We hope to post a preview segment of the film here by the end of the week. Stay tuned.

Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 8:37 AM EST
Updated: Monday, 14 December 2009 8:55 AM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (2) | Permalink | Share This Post
Saturday, 12 December 2009
On the anniversary of the Battle of Fredericksburg...

Here is the new trailer for our documentary film project on Sgt. Richard Kirkland. Titled "The Angel of Marye's Heights," this film combines expert commentary and dramatic recreations to tell an amazing story of courage and compassion. The official website will soon be launched by Clint Ross Productions. Our anticipated release date of the film is February 2010 and the National Civil War Life Foundation will be hosting the movie premier and reception here in Fredericksburg. Stay tuned in the coming weeks for a sneak preview and details on how you can help support this project.

 
 
PS. Here are the transcripts for my lecture on Richard Kirkland for anyone interested in learning more about the life and legacy of this remarkable man.

Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 2:53 PM EST
Updated: Monday, 14 December 2009 10:26 PM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (2) | Permalink | Share This Post
Thursday, 10 December 2009
NIFLA Online Auction

Today I was invited to contribute to an online auction hosted by a wonderful organization here in Fredericksburg called the National Institute of Family & Life Advocates. Starting on March 1, 2010, NIFLA will be auctioning off a number of fun and unique items to raise money for their efforts. The National Institute of Family and Life Advocates (NIFLA) is a charitable 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization which exists to provide life-affirming pregnancy help centers the best legal education, consultation, and training possible.

I have donated signed copies of The Southern Cross and Campfires at the Crossroads and I am also putting together a very special tour: In the Steps of Stonewall: this one-of-a-kind experience will take (up to 4) guests to local sites tracing the last days of Confederate Gen. Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson. The 4+ hour tour includes: Chancellorsville Battlefield sites, Jackson's wounding Trail and Monument, Jackson's arm burial-site at Ellwood, Jackson's Ambulance Route, and the Stonewell Jackson Shrine. Additional stops may be added as time permits. Date/time to be determined.

Visit the NIFLA auction to see what items are up for bid. You can also donate items.

Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 4:23 PM EST
Updated: Friday, 11 December 2009 2:42 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Wednesday, 9 December 2009
Another one down

Today I finished reading 1862: Stonewall Jackson's Valley Campaign by Peter Cozzens. My daily 3+ hour train commute is enabling me to complete 500+ page books in a little over two weeks, so I guess it’s not all bad that I never see daylight on workdays. This book left me with a variety of reactions and I am adding a great deal of newfound knowledge to my prep for a banquet talk that I am doing this summer at the CWHC Muster in Lexington titled Lion in the Valley: Stonewall Jackson's 1862 Valley Campaign.

Cozzens contribution is refreshingly original and does an excellent job of presenting the perspectives of both sides. In doing so we are given a very balanced presentation of the events from both Federal and Confederate witnesses, in both positive and negative lights. This book pulls no punches when taking commanders to task and clearly shows that even Jackson’s genius was flawed at times during this campaign. He was not tactically perfect by any means regardless of his troop’s tremendous accomplishments and his subordinates were not always on board with the general’s orders. I will be sure to keep Stonewall’s “boots on the ground” in my presentation, (which may surprise some people) and I now have some great recollections from the Union-side to add.

As a straight military-history, 1862 is a great read. The author does a very good job of presenting the engagements coherently and his tasteful use of maps compliments the narrative. As this particular campaign resulted in multiple battles and skirmishes, there are plenty of firsthand combat accounts, and I have a newfound appreciation for the suffering of both the soldiers and the civilian population. Cozzen’s writing style is also vivid and I am thankful that I have toured several of the fields he paints including the often overlooked Kernstown. As a result, I could easily envision the topography and primary sites of interest. To be honest, I was not aware of the number of fights that occurred in the valley during this period.

The most striking revelation for me (as a student of Jackson) is how much the author’s depiction of Stonewall reminds me of Gen. George S. Patton. I recall reading a quote from a WW2 veteran of the legendary 3rd Army in which he offered what is was like to fight under the tenacious tank commander. He said, “They called him [Patton] ‘Old blood and guts.” Stating that the moniker was accurate only to a point he added, “It was true…our blood and his guts.” The marches (and counter-marches) that were conducted by the Valley Army are hard to believe at times in both the sheer distance covered, and the natural obstacles that they traversed. Frankly, the simple movement of men during the campaign is equally astounding and disturbing. I would have understood one’s desire to desert after a third trip back up the mountain.

The ONLY disappointment with this book (and more of a personal issue), is the miniscule coverage of the death of Turner Ashby. It’s no secret that this controversial cavalryman is a favorite character of mine and I unashamedly included him in my Top 10 Confederate Generals feature that I penned for Civil War Historian magazine. Much to my dismay (as I anticipated reaching this event from the very first page) 1862 gives a brief recap of Ashby’s death and his postmortem evacuation. I really wanted to know more about the scene and the affect of the Black Knight’s death on the morale of his men. I’ll be quoting some tearful recollections from Ashby’s troopers in my talk and I wish that Cozzen would have spent a little more time doing the same. That said, I highly recommend 1862: Stonewall Jackson's Valley Campaign and will be using it as a valuable source for my talk.

Tomorrow I start reading The Civil War: Tullahoma to Meridian by Shelby Foote to finish out the year. 


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 2:20 PM EST
Updated: Thursday, 10 December 2009 8:28 AM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (1) | Permalink | Share This Post
Tuesday, 8 December 2009
Coming soon: Jan/Feb 2010 PAR

Tim Jacobs, the editor over at Patriots of the American Revolution was kind enough to mention me over on his magazine’s blog. It really is a blessing to have so many people behind you and I am very fortunate. All week I have received positive feedback and I feel rejuvenated as a historian. Any fears I had of changing genres have completely disappeared thanks to the support of my friends, readers, and colleagues. I just received a 7-page galley of my upcoming Monticello feature from associate editor Benjamin Smith and was completely blown away. The finished product looks spectacular and I can hardly wait for the Jan/Feb issue of PAR to be released. This article is only the first of many to come and it is a real privilege for me to write for Tim and Ben. My goal is to contribute an article each month if possible. My next piece may examine the post-war trials of Loyalists in the Fredericksburg area. Stay tuned and don’t forget to check out the current issue of Patriots of the American Revolution.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 12:08 PM EST
Updated: Monday, 14 December 2009 4:28 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Sunday, 6 December 2009
Christmas came early...



Thank you Mort.

Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 6:24 PM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (2) | Permalink | Share This Post
Monday, 30 November 2009
Marching on to new things...

I am done with the Civil War. What? Yep...

I just received word today that the editors at Patriots of the American Revolution are very pleased with the essay and photographs that I delivered this weekend. Mine will be the lead feature story in the upcoming January/February issue of PAR. I for one can’t wait to see it and I do believe that it’s the best magazine piece I've written to date. The subject of race and remembrance at Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello was a challenging topic and it has firmly cemented my interest in moving my studies into the colonial period, more specifically the lives and legacies of our Founding Fathers. Once again, the Civil War will remain a recurring subject, but all future projects are going to step back to an earlier time.

I have far more interest in exploring the years leading up to the Revolution than writing any more books on the War Between the States. I have published five Civil War titles to date and the last two releases have been both praised and accepted by the ACW community. My latest goal was to gain the endorsement of the NPS Eastern National bookstores and I accomplished that with Houses of the Holy and Campfires at the Crossroads. These titles have been legitimized by respected individuals whose approval had escaped me with my first three books.

It goes without saying that the local National Park Service does an incredible job in regards to preserving and presenting our local Civil War history, but they have admittedly shied away from the colonial period in lieu of private organizations cornering that market. With exceptionally historic places like Ferry Farm and Kenmore Plantation, there are plenty of early-American gems to be elaborated on. Someday I would love to write a book specifically on Thomas Jefferson’s experiences here in Fredericksburg when he drafted the Virginia Statute of Religious Freedom although I am not sure enough reference material exists to justify a narrative of that length.

Regardless, I am formally announcing my intentions to explore other historical periods as both a writer and a historian. From here on in (with the exception of ongoing commitments to the NCWLF, Mr. Kunstler, the 2010 CWH Muster, and the Richard Kirkland documentary) I am no longer a "Civil War historian." In fact, I would like to consider myself a "newly-inspired student of the colonial period" where I hope to learn as much, if not more, than my previous discipline. In other words, an enthusiastic amateur. It would be far too easy for me to stay in my comfort zone, but I need to evolve. I just took an incredibly challenging job with the USMS that has me up at 5am and out till 7pm, with a combined three-hour train ride, in a suit and tie. I could have continued to coast well into my 10th year at my old job, but cruise-control can stifle one’s ability to grow.

I NEED TO GROW, so I am essentially starting over in both my vocation and pastime. I hope you’ll all come along for the ride. My enthusiasm needs a kick in the pants and frankly, I am tired of reacting to other bloggers and rehashing the same old debates. You will see far less Civil War related posts here in the future and more pieces that reflect my new interests in the colonial period. Over the course of this year, I have read far more books in this era and I feel like I'm on the precipice of a whole new career where I have an abundance of history to learn - and even more to share.

Once I complete my CW commitments, I'm done. And from here on in, it's all about the Benjamins..."Franklins" that is.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 3:48 PM EST
Updated: Tuesday, 1 December 2009 9:04 AM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (4) | Permalink | Share This Post
Patience please

I can’t seem to keep up with all of the articles and blog postings that are going around in regards to the Spotsylvania Civil War Museum. We have a mandatory board meeting on December 13th. I promise to update the FLS, everyone here, and post an announcement on the NCWLF’s website once I have something significant to share. I have already promised reporter Dan Telvok an exclusive follow-up interview and between the two of us, you'll be well-informed. Our mission at the National Civil War Life Foundation remains. Our approach is another story. (Believe it or not, I envision a day when I will welcome Kevin Levin and his class to our museum and he will have nothing left to criticize because we did it right.)


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 8:43 AM EST
Updated: Monday, 30 November 2009 8:49 AM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Friday, 27 November 2009
Black Friday without the lines…

The Civil War in Spotsylvania: Confederate Campfires at the Crossroads features published memoirs, diaries, letters and testimonials from those who were there to give a fascinating look into the day-to-day experiences of camp life in the Confederate army. 

Historic Churches of Fredericksburg: Houses of the Holy recalls stories of rebellion, racism and reconstruction as experienced by Secessionists, Unionists and the African American population in Fredericksburg's landmark churches during the Civil War. 

The Southern Cross: A Civil War Devotional shares forty uplifting devotions, ten encouraging essays, a special sermon that was presented to the soldiers in the field and a short biographical tribute to six of the South's most pious commanders. 

Christian Cavalier: The Spiritual Legacy of J.E.B. Stuart presents an intimate portrait of the flamboyant Confederate Cavalry General J.E.B. Stuart and a testament to his devout service to both God and country. 

Onward Christian Soldier: The Spiritual Journey Of Stonewall presents a historical account of the military, personal, and spiritual life of General Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson who rose from the pains of a tragic childhood to become one of the South’s most celebrated soldiers.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 2:28 PM EST
Updated: Friday, 27 November 2009 2:38 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Thursday, 26 November 2009
The Naked Historian Thanksgiving Day Special
 
 

Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 4:25 PM EST
Updated: Thursday, 26 November 2009 4:25 PM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (1) | Permalink | Share This Post
Wednesday, 25 November 2009
One down, one to go...

If there is something good to say about my new three-hour commute, it is that I now have a daily-dedicated time for reading on the train. Yesterday I finished the Pulitzer Prize winner The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family by Annette Gordon-Reed and today I started reading Shenandoah 1862: Stonewall Jackson's Valley Campaign by Peter Cozzens. I would like to say that both books are simply for pleasure, but in all honesty, I am writing an article for the magazine Patriots of the American Revolution on how slavery is being interpreted at the new Monticello Visitor’s Center and researching material for a banquet speech I am doing next summer in Lexington on Stonewall's Valley Campaign. Regardless, I am experiencing great pleasure while reading both of these extraordinary titles.

The Hemings book is an exhaustively researched and incredibly thought-provoking (albeit infuriating at times) portrait of an African-American family and I plan on reading the counter-argument In Defense of Thomas Jefferson: The Sally Hemings Sex Scandal by William G. Hyland Jr. as well. This year I read four books on Thomas Jefferson and although I had intended to keep that streak alive for the remainder of 2009, I think I need a break from TJ, hence the Stonewall Jackson book. That title looks be a great one to finish out the year as it intentionally sets out to present BOTH the Confederate and Union impressions of that military affair (the first study on the subject to do so). I may post some impressions on this one as I progress.

As this will be my last post before the holiday I want to wish each and every one of you a blessed Thanksgiving.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 9:20 AM EST
Updated: Wednesday, 25 November 2009 12:20 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Tuesday, 24 November 2009
Shout out to Dan Telvok

Reporter Dan Telvok posted a reaction to my last post on his blog. I would like to address that by saying that I am collectively commenting on BOTH articles that were written by Dan (and are linked below). The first article that generated the critical comments on the FLS site was the primary one that caught my attention. I in no way meant to say that Dan’s reporting was inaccurate. I was merely trying to say that Terry's comments at the time were in regards to his own economic situation and did not reflect the foundation’s feelings. He was obviously angry in the first interview and it was reflected in the piece. The second article was an addition to that and I included it in my post as it has also generated some comments on other blogs.

I stand by my statements that the National Civil War Life Foundation is still interested in our original mission and Spotsylvania as a location. I apologize if my post came off as being critical of Dan or the Free Lance-Star. He wrote what he was told. What he was told however, was stated out of frustration by an individual who regrets saying it.

I have a longstanding relationship with the Fredericksburg newspaper and nothing but respect for the FLS's staff. The ‘assumptions’ that I am alluding to in my post are taken from the tone of the comments and Mr. Thomann’s emotions at the time, not by the pen of Mr. Telvok. My apologies if this was implied in my post below. My goal is simply to reinforce the notion that the NCWLF’s mission carries on. If I offended Mr. Telvok in the process I apologize.

ADDED: Dan and I have chatted, all is well, and he is planning on doing a follow-up article w/ me after our Dec. 13 board meeting. Stay tuned.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 4:32 PM EST
Updated: Wednesday, 25 November 2009 9:51 AM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (1) | Permalink | Share This Post
The truth about Spotsylvania’s Civil War Museum

I would like to take a moment to address an issue that has come to my knowledge today. Several bloggers have commented (here and here) on a couple articles that recently appeared in The Free Lance-Star in regards to the closing and relocation of the Civil War Life Soldier’s Museum here in Spotsylvania. As I am available to speak officially for the National Civil War Life Foundation, I will use my blog to comment.

Although these bloggers are thoughtfully commenting on what they have read online, there is some unintentional misinformation being shared that requires clarity. (I emailed some update info to Kevin Levin, who thankfully brought the blog discussions to my attention, but he has not commented on it yet.) The two FLS articles quoted are located here and here. They may present the notion that the museum and related foundation are severing all ties to Spotsylvania County and moving on to other things. This is incorrect, although there is partial truths in these "changes." Here are the facts:

Yes, Terry Thomann has indeed closed the original Civil War Life Soldier’s Museum in Massaponax and moved his entire gift shop (and a portion of the museums’ collection and attractions) to Old Town Fredericksburg in what used to be the Fredericksburg Historical Prints store. This move took place simply as an economic necessity as the old location was not generating the anticipated business. As the economy continues to suffer, so do historically-themed establishments that rely on tourism. The NCWLF’s Spotsylvania museum venture and Mr. Thomann’s gift shop are two different entities (although they are intertwined as the existing artifact collection belongs to the proprietor of both.)

In order to stay in business, a move was an absolute and when the downtown location became available, Mr. Thomann took it. In retrospect, Terry admits venting some of his frustrations to the first article's reporter and regretfully they made it into the story. The writer was simply quoting what he thought were decisions that had already been made. They were not and Terry has met with individuals from the county and the situation is being discussed en route to being resolved. There is a NCWLF board meeting coming up in a few weeks and I will be sure to update both the media and readers here of new information as it becomes available.

The bottom line is this: The National Civil War Life Foundation is still on the same mission, to build an all-inclusive museum that tells the entire story of the Civil War from all sides. We are still looking at Spotsylvania as a location. We are planning on holding some special events at the new store location to generate additional interest in this project. We are still sponsoring the documentary film on Richard Kirkland that is slated for release in February 2010. We are in talks with Mort Kunstler’s rep about having an exclusive gallery section at both the existing and future locations. We will be updating the website soon to reflect these minor changes that do not affect our mission. And we want to assure all of our supporters that our prime directive remains:

To operate a national museum and research center that preserves and interprets the human story of the American Civil War and connects the lives of all people of that era to the Nation today.

Like many of our area's business owners, Mr. Thomann is doing whatever he has to in order to financially take care of his family. Costs were stacking up and the visitations were dropping. This relocation from a secluded strip-mall in Spotsylvania to Fredericksburg’s main street will hopefully help him fulfill his needs. Our job as a foundation is to stay focused on opening a new museum and we will continue to work hard to accomplish our goal. Once again, this article (and this move) has no bearing on the NCWLF's intent or vision. It simply means that a new gift shop is now open in downtown Fredericksburg with one of the largest inventories in the area. This shop also offers CW artifacts and exhibits, a working tin-type photo studio, and a Civil War in 3D photography show. 

Hopefully that can set the record straight for now and the responsive bloggers will caveat their posts. They weren't wrong, they were simply commenting on articles that echoed the emotions of a man who is trying to gain some sense of financial security and provide a service to the community. Any additional questions can be sent to me directly and I will be more than happy to comment (if I can).

Thank you.
Michael Aubrecht
Vice-Chairman, NCWLF

ADDED: Of course I wouldn’t suspect anything less from Mr. Levin who I cordially emailed twice today in an effort to prevent him from spreading misinformation. Beyond apologizing for a recent post that I directed at him then removed, I also tried to explain what was going on as I am an insider. He was kind enough to post this:

Update: This morning I received additional information from a member of the museum’s Board of Directors. For a number of reasons I am not going to include that information since it is so confusing that I can’t make heads or tails of it. One wonders whether this individual even knew about the closing before this morning. I am more than happy to provide a link to an official statement on the museum’s website. It is curious that a statement wasn’t posted before this recent decision was made.

What a class act... YES Kevin, I knew. Once again, you have proven that you are a jerk and I wish you nothing but the best. The very fact that you refuse to reply to my communications or acknowledge or inform your readers of my post-explanation reveals that your own personal dislike of me supersedes any integrity on your blog.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 9:38 AM EST
Updated: Tuesday, 24 November 2009 10:31 PM EST
Post Comment | View Comments (1) | Permalink | Share This Post
Friday, 20 November 2009
Books now available at NPS stores

I was just informed today that my last two books with The History Press, Historical Churches of Fredericksburg: Houses of the Holy and The Civil War in Spotsylvania County: Confederate Campfires at the Crossroads, are being carried at the National Park Service (Eastern National) bookstores in our area. I am so grateful for this validation of my work and am planning to hold a book signing event at the Fredericksburg branch in the Spring. I am also in the process of setting up a Winter signing and talk on my camp book at the new Civil War Life Soldier’s Museum, which is now located in Old Town Fredericksburg at the former Fredericksburg Historical Prints location. Stay tuned for details on both events.

Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 9:14 AM EST
Updated: Friday, 20 November 2009 10:15 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Exclusive Interview

A few years ago I had the pleasure of sharing space at a book signing event with some very generous folks from Ertel Publishing. As a result, I was commissioned to write a couple features for one of their most popular publications, Civil War Historian magazine. Over the next year I penned a lengthy article on baseball during the Civil War that received a lot of acclaim, as well as an intentionally controversial piece in which I ranked the top ten Confederate generals. One of the relationships that blossomed from this commission was a friendship with the editor Benjamin Smith. Ironically, just as my studies have moved further back in our nation’s history, so has Ben’s publishing efforts. Both of us share new interests in the lives and legacies of our Founding Fathers and the revolution that they inspired.

Although I will still continue to support my existing Civil War-era efforts, new projects will likely involve the colonial period. My recent work with The Thomas Jefferson Project for instance has been well-received. A couple weeks ago I accepted an invitation to contribute a feature-length study to Ben’s newest pub-affiliation Patriots of the American Revolution. As a result, I have enthusiastically decided to submit a more detailed and formal study of my look at how slavery is being interpreted at the new Monticello Visitors Center. I also asked Ben if he would be interested in doing a short interview to introduce my readers to what has quickly become one of the most original and informative historical magazines out there. He graciously accepted and our conversation is as follows:

[NOTE: Patriots of the American Revolution is a bi-monthly, full-color, 60-page publication. It is owned by Three Patriots, LLC, and published by Ertel Publishing. Tim Jacobs is its Editor and previous owner; Ben the Associate Editor]

Q: For how long has Patriots of the American Revolution been published? How and why did it begin?

A: The magazine’s editor, Tim Jacobs, started publishing the magazine in 2008. The concept for the publication began out of Tim’s desire to honor his ancestor, Ezekiel Jacobs, who served in the in the Connecticut Militia during the American Revolution. After learning and researching much of Ezekiel’s life and time in the war, Tim wrote an article about him--but couldn’t find a publication to submit the piece. And that was the genesis of Patriots of the American Revolution. Tim wanted to create a venue for people in which they could honor their Patriot ancestors. Today, the magazine still features profiles about people’s Patriot ancestors, but it has grown to include interesting articles about the leaders and battles of the Revolution, as well as research on early American culture.

Q: Explain this growth a little more. For example, how did you get involved?

A: This is where the story about the magazine gets interesting. I’ve been working for Ertel Publishing--a magazine publisher located in Yellow Springs, Ohio—since early 2007. We design and publish several magazines, most of which are somewhat historical in nature. Some of the magazines are owned by Ertel Publishing; some of the magazines are owned by people who hire us to do the design work and assist with editing and marketing.  In June of 2008, I came across the magazine’s original website, and thought it might be the perfect sort of magazine for us to design. I called Tim and we hit it off; he and I have a lot in common. So Ertel Publishing started to design Patriots of the American Revolution, and provided Tim with some very basic marketing/PR assistance. The magazine started to grow, but not at the rate that Tim needed it grow by; it’s expensive publishing your own magazine. So in the summer of 2009, three of us here at Ertel Publishing—myself; our General Manager, Vicki McClellan; and our President, Patrick Ertel—formed a company called Three Patriots, LLC and bought the magazine from Tim. However, we kept Tim on as the Editor, and hired Ertel Publishing to continue designing the magazine. That’s when I became Associate Editor.

Q: Has the look or direction of the magazine changed since Three Patriots, LLC purchased it?

A: It has, and quite a bit. The page number has grown from 34 pages to 60 pages, and the magazine is now a bi-monthly publication; it used to be a quarterly. Also, we have added new departments, such as “Culture, Art, & Conflict” and “Allies & Enemies.”

Q: What are some of the other departments that readers can find in each issue?

A: One of our most popular departments is “Notable Bloodlines,” which is written by Tim Jacobs. He traces the family history of a celebrity—such as Ernest Hemingway, or Muhammad Ali—back to the American Revolution, and illuminates the lives and achievements of the celebrity’s Patriot ancestors. We also have a department called “The American Revolution Today,” which focuses on current preservation efforts and historic sites pertaining to the Revolution. Personally, my favorite department is “The American Revolution Month-by-Month.”

Q: What kind of featured articles do you publish?

A: All kinds. Just to give you an idea, I’ll list some of the topics that have appeared in the past two issues: the Battle of Saratoga; the myth of the Jersey Devil; Molly Pitcher; Washington Irving; the Massacre of Cherry Valley; the Turtle submarine; Thomas Paine; and British newspaper coverage of the Battle of Trenton.

Q: What issue are you currently working on?

A: The January/February 2010 issue, which will actually print and ship in the middle of this December.

Q: Can you give readers a sneak peek into what they can expect to see in the upcoming issue?

A: Sure! We have a wonderful article about Betty Zane, a 16-year-old girl who helped Patriots win a battle against British and American Indian soldiers in present-day West Virginia.   We also have an article on the so-called Forage War, which occurred in New Jersey during the winter of 1777. Finally, our department called “Culture, Art, & Conflict” focuses on how Loyalists were treated by Patriots during the war. For more information, you’ll just have to check out our website on a regular basis:
www.patriotsar.com.

Q: How much is a subscription?

A: The cost is $29.95 for six issues, per year.

Q: Who would you recommend a subscription to?

A: To anyone who likes to read about early American history. We actually cover events from the French and Indian War, through the Revolution, to the War of 1812; all three of those events are connected. Also, I would recommend a subscription to anyone who enjoys the simple art of reading a magazine. I mean, I love blogs. I write a blog for Ertel Publishing, and Tim writes a blog for the magazine. Blogs are incredibly useful and vital. But at the end of a long day, I like to sit at home, put up my feet, and unwind with a magazine. Patriots of the American Revolution is the kind of magazine I would like to decompress with. It’s interesting, educational, well-written, and uses a lot of fine art; it looks nice. Its easy on the eyes. Of course, I am biased!

For more information about Patriots of the American Revolution, please visit
www.patriotsar.com.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 8:53 AM EST
Updated: Friday, 20 November 2009 12:17 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Sunday, 15 November 2009
The Gray Ghost: Mosby in Warrenton, January 18, 1863

Here's the official copy I penned for the latest release from Mort Künstler: Ordering information

Following the Confederate Congress's Partisan Ranger Act of 1862, Major General J.E.B. Stuart appointed one of his most gifted scouts, First Lieutenant John Singleton Mosby, to lead the 43rd Battalion Virginia Cavalry. "Mosby's Rangers," as they would be called, were formed that following January as the winter of 1863 blanketed the Virginia countryside.

On the 18th of that month, while en route from Fredericksburg to Upper Fauquier, Mosby and fifteen men detached from the 1st Virginia Cavalry stopped off in the town of Warrenton to dine at the renowned Warren-Green Hotel. In November of 1862, Union General George B. McClellan had bid his troops farewell on the steps of this tavern after being relieved of his command by President Abraham Lincoln. This evening however, the Warren-Green witnessed the birth of a new command whose reputation would grow to epic proportions.

This unique group represented twelve native Virginians and three Marylanders who had been handpicked by Mosby himself. They formed the original nucleus of "Mosby's Rangers," and together they would provide intelligence for the Army of Northern Virginia, while also causing disruptions along the Union army supply lines. Their unique ability to evade Federal pursuers earned their commander the nickname of "The Gray Ghost," as he and his troops appeared to vanish whenever they ventured into harm's way.

Mosby himself recalled their unique mission when he wrote, "My purpose was to weaken the armies invading Virginia, by harassing their rear... to destroy supply trains, to break up the means of conveying intelligence, and thus isolating an army from its base, as well as its different corps from each other, to confuse their plans by capturing their dispatches, are the objects of partisan war. It is just as legitimate to fight an enemy in the rear as in the front. The only difference is in the danger."

After the South's surrender at Appomattox Courthouse in 1865, Mosby begrudgingly disbanded his rangers, vowing to never surrender formally. He later returned to the town of Warrenton to conduct his law practice and often dined at the Warren-Green Hotel.

Mort Künstler's Comments:

It has been ten years since I last painted the beautiful Warrenton County Courthouse featured in "The Bravest of the Brave." In addition, it has been twelve years since I last painted John Singleton Mosby in "While the Enemy Rests." That is much too long, in my opinion.

I felt it would be wonderful if I could combine both subjects in one painting. Placing Mosby in Warrenton was easy because he operated often out of that area. But there were still a number of obstacles. I wanted to capture a significant moment in his storied career and I also wanted a snow scene. I learned that his first independent command was formed in Warrenton and his original fifteen men stopped off at the Warren-Green Hotel for dinner on January 18, 1863.

By moving my viewpoint around to what is now the Alexandria Pike, I realized that I would not only get a very different angle of the Courthouse from the previous painting, but I could also get the Warren-Green Hotel in the background. I quickly called my good friend and colleague, Dr. James I. Robertson, Jr. and was delighted to learn that it was indeed a bitterly cold windy day that had turned everything white and icy. This gave me my snow scene.

With this newfound knowledge I imagined the difficulties of getting up the hill on the Alexandria Pike, facing the front of the Courthouse. Although they plowed the roads with horse drawn equipment, wagons and carts would have been rendered immobile and abandoned. The trees around the Courthouse today almost obliterate the building from view on Alexandria Pike, so painting the structure accurately was very challenging. Historian Richard Deardoff of Warrenton was of great assistance with research for this painting.

As the men rode up the hill on Court Street alongside the Courthouse, none of them could have imagined the unparalleled success and fame that would subsequently come to the young lieutenant. Mosby himself could not have foreseen the reputation he would gain.

I feel a great sense of satisfaction from this painting, as I was able to combine all of the desired elements into a single image. This includes placing "The Gray Ghost" and his men in front of the Warrenton County Courthouse, on a significant date in their formation, in the beautiful Virginia snow.

This year the paper prints feature the Mosby Heritage Area Association's* seal, which is sure to make it a highly collectible print. *The MAHA's mission is to promote the preservation of the historic, cultural and scenic resources of the Mosby Heritage Area.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 7:54 AM EST
Updated: Sunday, 15 November 2009 7:57 AM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
Friday, 30 October 2009
Race and remembrance

Yesterday’s trip to Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello was a very fruitful day. This was my first time back since August of 2007 and there have been some wonderful additions to the site in my absence. Before I begin with what I hope will be a very original and insightful post, I do have to share three, very important revelations:

1. Uploading video from your Blackberry while standing on top of a mountain is an exercise in futility.
2. IF you take a photo in the new exhibit hall using a flash, you will set off an alarm (trust me).
3. The new Visitor’s Center is excellent, although I believe there are far less artifacts on display.

Thursday’s expedition had a very important goal, to specifically examine how slavery is now being interpreted and presented at the new Monticello. In one of my essays written for The Jefferson Project, I recalled how I typically glanced over the issue of racism when visiting Jefferson’s home. Today, my eyes have been opened to examining these uncomfortable issues and acknowledging the hypocrisy that existed in the practices of the Founding Fathers. Please note that my respect for this man has not changed, Jefferson was both brilliant and inspiring. The difference is that I now remain in awe of a man who was quite imperfect, just like the rest of us.

My revelation came as I began to take a more critical look at the life and legacy of Thomas Jefferson. Recently I posted here and here on my reading of Gary Wills’ book “Negro President” Jefferson and the Slave Power, as well as The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family by Annette Gordon-Reed. Admittedly, I had no idea how influential the institution of human bondage was to the establishment and operation of our nation’s earliest federal government. For example, the “three-fifths [slave] clause” of the Constitution tremendously benefited men like Thomas Jefferson and enabled slaveholders to retain high-level political positions for generations.

It was with this newfound perspective that I set out to revisit Jefferson's home. I am aware of some fellow CW bloggers who are re-examining race and memory in regards to the Civil War, but I believe I am the first to take this approach with the newly updated Monticello. My post today looks at four major parts of the visitor’s experience: the visitor’s center and gallery, the house tour, Mulberry Row, and the new guidebook. I took extra special care to record via photo, video, and notes, how slavery was interpreted and presented at each of these venues. (Unfortunately, the video aspect was not successful as I do not believe silent camera pans of displays are worth your time. Therefore I am sticking with the photos and my own observations.)

The objective of this post is to inspire you to visit Monticello just as I did, with a fresh curiosity and newfound perspective. (All photographs were taken on site.)

1. Visitor's Center

First up is the new Monticello Visitors Center and Smith Education Center. There are two main galleries at this location (along with a theater, café, gift shop, and research library). Both exhibit halls feature specific displays dealing with slavery and the labor force at Monticello. Both sections appear dedicated to recognizing the contributions of the slave community. In the upstairs gallery there is a biography card on Issac Jefferson who had served as a blacksmith, tinsmith, and nailer. You may remember that Issac’s memoirs were recorded by an interviewer and remain among the most insightful narratives about the day-to-day lives of Monticello’s inhabitants. Isaac held a sincere affection for his owner and was reported as saying, “Old Master was very kind to servants.” (For additional quotes see Jefferson at Monticello, Recollections of a Monticello Slave and a Monticello Overseer. Edited by James Adam Bear, Jr.).

Next to Issac’s display are matching bios of John Hemings, a tremendously skilled woodworker who crafted much of the interior woodwork of Jefferson’s house at Poplar Forest, as well the most famous of all Monticello’s slaves, Sally Hemings. Of course her relationship with Thomas Jefferson has been the subject of great controversy. According to the Thomas Jefferson Foundation’s official statement on the matter: “Although the relationship between Jefferson and Sally Hemings has been for many years, and will surely continue to be, a subject of intense interest to historians and the public, the evidence is not definitive, and the complete story may never be known. The Foundation encourages its visitors and patrons, based on what evidence does exist, to make up their own minds as to the true nature of the relationship.”

This stance continues today in various publications on the matter including the visitor’s handbook (more on that later). In addition to these bio cards, artifacts including some of the slave’s handiwork are on display. The craftsmanship that these men achieved, made even more impressively with the lack of technology, is beyond remarkable. Slave labor at Monticello was definitely skilled labor.

In the downstairs gallery, a large display titled “Those Who Built Monticello” presents the tradesmen, free and enslaved, as well as the tools they used to construct Jefferson’s magnificent estate. According to the plaque, “Jefferson required highly-skilled workmen to realize his vision for Monticello. In Philadelphia in 1798 he engaged James Dinsmore, an Irish house joiner, to take charge of the ongoing construction in his absences. Dinsmore worked closely with enslaved joiner John Hemings to create much of Monticello’s fine woodwork. The team of joiners also included James Oldham (1801-04) and John Neilson (1805-09), and another enslaved man, Lewis...”

It continued, “John Hemings, the son of Elizabeth (Betty) Hemings, apprenticed under Dinsmore and hired joiners. He became an accomplished craftsman, succeeded Dinsmore as head joiner in 1809, and trained other slaves in his trade, including his nephews Madison and Eston Hemings. A Monticello overseer recalled that Hemings ‘could make anything that was wanted in woodwork.’ He made fine furniture, a landau carriage, and much of the interior woodwork at Poplar Forest. Jefferson freed Hemings in his will and gave him all the tools of his shop. Continuing to work for the Jefferson family, Hemings lived for several more years at Monticello with his wife, Priscilla.”

2. House and Dependencies Tour

Second in my investigation, the traditional house tour and dependency exhibits. Nothing major has changed noticeably at the top of the hill, although the guided tours are now more open to discussing the institution of slavery and how it was a crucial element in the construction, maintenance and operation of Monticello. Our guide immediately made a point of presenting Jefferson as a typical Virginia plantation owner who had established his lifestyle on the benefits of slave labor. She quoted Jefferson as saying that he abhorred slavery, and believed that he looked at his slaves with a paternalistic view, that they were children who required his supervision. She then countered that notion by saying that dozens of Monticello’s 200 slaves had been traded off by Jefferson and that if one judged him by his deeds and not his words, slavery was something that benefited him greatly. Other than the usual mention of the house staff's chores and showing the dumbwaiters and kitchen carousel, the rest of the tour steered clear of the topic.

Underneath the house, there were several displays in the center alcove presenting the servant’s quarters, found artifacts, and slave life including that of Issac Jefferson. The kitchen areas in particular presented how Jefferson had his slave cooks trained by French chefs in the traditional dish preparations of the time. Adjacent quarters presented the life of a slave named Joseph Fossett. The plaque reads, “Joseph Fossett (1780-1858) was the grandson of Elizabeth (Betty Hemings) and the son of Mary Hemings Bell, who became free in the 1790s while her son remained a slave at Monticello. According to overseer Edmund Backon, Fossett, a blacksmith, was ‘a very fine workman; could do anything it was necessary to do with steel or iron.’ Joseph and Edith Fossett had ten children, from James, born in the President’s House in 1805, to Jesse, born in 1830. Although Joseph Fossett was freed in Jefferson’s will, his wife and children were sold at the Monticello estate auction in 1827. He continued to work as a blacksmith and, with the help of his mother and other free family members, was able to purchase the freedom of Edith and some of their children. They moved to Cincinnati, Ohio, in the 1840s. In 1850 their son Peter, who left a number of recollections of his life, became free and joined his family in Cincinnati, where he was a prominent caterer and Baptist minister.”

3. Mulberry Row

Third and perhaps the most direct display of slave life at Monticello is the stops along Mulberry Row. In addition to traditional placards, brick ruins mark the areas of significance. Named for the mulberry trees planted along it, Mulberry Row was the center of plantation activity at Monticello from the 1770s to Jefferson’s death in 1826. Five log dwellings for slaves were located on Mulberry Row in 1796. The Mulberry Row cabins were occupied mainly by household servants -- women who did the cooking, washing, house cleaning, sewing, and child tending. According to Monticello’s website, “Not all slaves lived on Mulberry Row. A small number who were household servants lived in rooms in the basement-level dependency wings of Monticello, and others lived in cabins located elsewhere at Monticello and outlying farms.”

Stops along the way include slave dwellings, workman’s house, storehouse, blacksmith shop, nailery and a joinery. Some people may not be aware that all building materials including Monticello’s bricks and nails were made on site. I was surprised to learn that white workers also lived along this section of the estate. The T.J. Foundation states that, “A blacksmith shop was built on this site about 1793. Here Jefferson’s slaves Little George, Moses, and Joe Fossett shoed horses, repaired the metal parts of plows and hoes, replaced gun parts, and made the iron portions of the carriages that Jefferson designed. Neighboring farmers brought work to the shop as well, and the slave blacksmiths were given a percentage of the profits of their labor. In 1794, Jefferson added a nailmaking operation to the shop, in an effort to provide an additional source of income. Nailrod was shipped to Monticello by water from Philadelphia and was hammered into nails by as many as fourteen young male slaves, aged ten to sixteen.”

The crumbled foundation remains of a typical Mulberry Row slave cabin. According to the plaque, the structures were approximately 20 ft. x 12 ft., constructed of logs on a stone foundation, with a wood chimney and earth floor. These buildings overlooked the main produce gardens. Today there is a special Plantation Tour available that covers the slave community and its daily contribution in more detail. Mulberry Row is a main focal point of the walking tour.


(Excerpt: In 1796 there were 110 African-Americans living on the 5,000-acre plantation, almost half of them children.)

4. Monticello Visitor's Guidebook

Fourth and finally, my attentions were drawn to the newly updated Monticello Visitor’s Guide. I always save my brochures, maps and handouts when touring historical sites and was able to refer back to the old version. I also had a children’s handout from 2007 which I have always been curious about. The illustrations that explain to children the day-to-day life at Monticello depict slaves happily cooking in the kitchen and playing with the Jefferson children around the fish pond. No doubt slave-master relationships like this existed, but these representations seemed a little too “happy-go-lucky” for my tastes. Of course little children are far too young to understand or comprehend the issues of slavery, but these candy-coated drawings were over the top.

The new Monticello guidebook features two large spreads dealing with slave labor. The first is titled “Mulberry Row” and includes an illustrated map of the grounds and photographs of artifacts. Once again Issac Jefferson makes an appearance (clearly the most exhibited slave on the premises). A section on the Storehouse states, “In 1796 Jefferson recorded that the log building here was used for storing iron and nail rod for the blacksmith shop and nailery. It also served over time for tinsmithing and nail manufacture and as a dwelling. A slave named Issac Jefferson, trained as a tinsmith in Philadelphia, briefly operated the tin shop.”

The second spread is titled “The Plantation” and deals specifically with the institution of slavery. It states, “Most of Jefferson’s slaves came to him by inheritance – 20 from his father and 135 from his father-in-law. In 1782, he was the largest slaveholder in Albemarle County. For most of his life he was the owner of 200 slaves, two-thirds of them at Monticello and one-third at Poplar Forest, his plantation in Bedford County.” A photograph of Jefferson’s record of slaves compliments the copy and a sidebar deals directly with the subjects of enslaved families and Sally Hemings. Both of these are new additions and bear quoting here:

“Enslaved Families: A number of extended families lived in bondage at Monticello for three or more generations, facilitating Jefferson’s operations as farm laborers, artisans, tradesmen and domestic workers. Among them were the children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren of Elizabeth Hemings, David and Isabel Hern, Edward and Jane Gillette, and James and Cate Hubbard. Nights, Sundays, and holidays provided the only opportunities to socialize and nurture their connections that united them as a community. Like their fellows across the South, Monticello slaves resisted slavery’s dehumanizing effects by filling this time with expressions of a rich culture: gardening, needlework, music, religious practice. They were part of a cultural and spiritual life that flourished independent of their masters.”

“Sally Hemings: That Thomas Jefferson fathered children with Sally Hemings, an enslaved ladies’ maid at Monticello, entered the public arena during his first term as president, and it has remained a subject of discussion and disagreement for more than two centuries. DNA tests results released in 1998 indicated a genetic link between the Jefferson and Hemings families. Thomas Jefferson Foundation historians believe that the weight of existing evidence indicates a high probability that Thomas Jefferson was the father of Sally Hemings’ son Eston (born 1808), and that he was likely the father of all her known children. The evidence is not definitive, however, and the complete story may never be known.” (Our friend Richard Williams recently posted some thoughts on his blog about a book by William G. Hyland Jr. titled In Defense of Thomas Jefferson: The Sally Hemings Sex Scandal, which takes the opposite stance.)

I have to admit that this trip to Monticello yielded a variety of different conclusions for me. The Thomas Jefferson that I recognize today was a man who may very well have held a sincere paternalistic fondness for his slaves, but at the same time, he held them in the chains of bondage. Despite the fact that many of his servants received specialized training and developed trades that resulted in the creation of great things, they were simultaneously denied the basic principle of freedom. This is where the contradiction of the man who penned the Declaration of Independence lies. Thomas Jefferson was an extraordinary man whose contributions to this country cannot be denied, but he was also a man who held racist views of the period. This is an undeniable truth.

Thankfully, the folks at Monticello are not shying away from this aspect of Jefferson’s life and the Foundation has made great strides to include an African-American presence in their presentation. It not only fills a void of far too neglected history, it also makes Thomas Jefferson human. Try to keep this in mind the next time that you visit Monticello and see if you too leave with a broader understanding of this remarkable, yet flawed Founding Father.

UPDATE: One additional area that fits the attention of this study is the African-American graveyard that is located on the grounds of the estate. According to the sign, this cemetery is the final resting place of 40+ blacks who lived in slavery at Monticello from 1770-1827. It adds that although the names of Jefferson's slaves were known, it has not been possible to identify any of those buried here. This is perhaps one of the most telling of all the exhibits as a separate burial plot personified the society of segregation that even in death, existed at Thomas Jefferson's Monticello.


Posted by ny5/pinstripepress at 8:45 PM EDT
Updated: Monday, 2 November 2009 1:34 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post

Newer | Latest | Older